Gouvernance

actualités internationales Gouvernance Normes d'encadrement Nouvelles diverses

Sentinelles : un rôle essentiel en gouvernance comme le rappelle Thomas Cook

PWC est dans l’eau chaude ! Selon le très sérieux Financial Times, « PwC accused of conflict over dual role at Thomas Cook » (20 octobre 2019).

Extrait :

PwC has been accused of a conflict of interest for advising senior executives at Thomas Cook on their pay and bonuses while it was the auditor of the now-collapsed travel group. The revelation it provided remuneration advice comes amid scrutiny of Thomas Cook’s accounting methods and criticism by MPs of millions of pounds in bonuses paid to board members in the years before it went bust last month. The travel company used a controversial accounting policy under which it stripped out “exceptional items” totalling £1.8bn over eight years, flattering the company’s headline financial results. The resulting underlying operating profit figure was used to calculate bonuses for Thomas Cook executives. PwC signed off the policy as Thomas Cook’s auditor between 2008 and 2016. However, subsequent auditor EY raised concerns over the “identification and approval of separately disclosed items” when it took on the role in 2017. About £28m of such costs were reclassified that year, reducing underlying earnings and triggering a profit warning. Executives at PwC and EY will be grilled by MPs over their work for Thomas Cook on Tuesday. UK accountants have been banned from providing advice on the remuneration of directors at the companies they audit since 2016. The head of audit at a rival firm to PwC said: “Regardless of the rules, I’d have felt really uncomfortable offering remuneration advice to an audit client. I’ve never done it and I wouldn’t ever do it.” They said PwC’s double role represented a “clear conflict” of interest. “PwC was advising on a remuneration scheme that protected management from exceptional items, while at the same time it was auditing the allocation of exceptional items,” the person said. A board member at another large accounting firm said: “Providing remuneration advice to audit clients is not allowed now for good reason.” PwC earned £4m providing “recruitment and remuneration” advice to Thomas Cook between 2007 and 2012, its accounts show.

À la prochaine…